Justin Desautels-Stein —
I wasn’t at all sure what to do after I was first asked to teach 1L Property Law. Not only was it an unexpected addition to my courseload, my background was in legal history and critical theory on the one side and in international law on the other, and the idea of picking up a first year private law course, just a couple years before going up for tenure, seemed crazy. Some colleagues suggested a copy and paste method for teaching the course: “Just grab a syllabus from someone you respect, assign their book, and stay one or two classes ahead of the students.” At first this seemed like the way to go. It would certainly save time and allow me to focus on my tenure pieces. But once I started reading the syllabi closely, the random doctrines seemed to beg for a narrative, and as it happened, I was already at work on just such a narrative in the history of American Legal Thought. It was a narrative that I had been developing within a broad project to revitalize the first wave of critical legal studies (circa 1975-1984). Thankfully, I had some very helpful (and certainly critical) support from veterans Kristen Carpenter and Dan Ernst, and the eventual result was a Property Law course developed out of my critical legal studies perspective on legal history. More broadly, it was this approach that also ended up working itself into what became a book, The Jurisprudence of Style (“JoS”). My explanation here about how I came to teach property “from the left” will draw heavily on that book, which is largely a history of law and political economy in the United States from a structuralist point of view.